| 28/09/09 | Barnsley A | 4 | 4 | University A |
| 28/09/09 | Chesterfield A | 3½ | 4½ | Worksop A |
| 30/09/09 | Nomads B | 3 | 5 | Nomads A |
| 07/10/09 | Ecclesall A | 6½ | 1½ | Nomads B |
| 09/10/09 | Rotherham Jnrs. A | 3 | 5 | Barnsley A |
| 19/10/09 | Barnsley A | 7 | 1 | Clay Cross |
| 19/10/09 | Worksop A | 4½ | 3½ | Ecclesall A |
| 20/10/09 | University A | 5 | 3 | Rotherham Jnrs. A |
| 21/10/09 | Nomads A | 4½ | 3½ | Nomads B |
| 27/10/09 | Clay Cross | 1 | 7 | Barnsley A |
| 28/10/09 | Nomads B | 5 | 3 | Ecclesall A |
| 02/11/09 | Chesterfield A | 5½ | 2½ | Ecclesall A |
| 03/11/09 | University A | 3½ | 4½ | Nomads B |
| 04/11/09 | Nomads A | 5½ | 2½ | Worksop A |
| 16/11/09 | Chesterfield A | 5 | 3 | Nomads A |
| 17/11/09 | University A | 4 | 4 | Clay Cross |
| 20/11/09 | Rotherham Jnrs. A | 5 | 3 | Ecclesall A |
| 24/11/09 | Clay Cross | 3 | 5 | Ecclesall A |
| 25/11/09 | Nomads A | 5 | 3 | Rotherham Jnrs. A |
| 30/11/09 | Worksop A | 3 | 5 | Rotherham Jnrs. A |
| 01/12/09 | University A | 3 | 5 | Nomads A |
| 02/12/09 | Nomads B | 2 | 6 | Chesterfield A |
| 07/12/09 | Barnsley A | 4 | 4 | Worksop A |
| 07/12/09 | Chesterfield A | 7 | 1 | Clay Cross |
| 09/12/09 | Ecclesall A | 3½ | 4½ | University A |
| 11/12/09 | Rotherham Jnrs. A | 6 | 2 | Nomads B |
| 15/12/09 | Clay Cross | 3½ | 4½ | University A |
| 16/12/09 | Nomads A | 7 | 1 | Barnsley A |
| 18/01/10 | Barnsley A | 3 | 5 | Rotherham Jnrs. A |
| 19/01/10 | Clay Cross | 2½ | 5½ | Nomads A |
| 19/01/10 | University A | 6½ | 1½ | Worksop A |
| 25/01/10 | Barnsley A | 2½ | 5½ | Ecclesall A |
| 25/01/10 | Worksop A | 5 | 3 | Nomads B |
| 27/01/10 | Nomads A | 5 | 3 | Chesterfield A |
| 29/01/10 | Rotherham Jnrs. A | 3½ | 4½ | University A |
| 01/02/10 | Worksop A | 5½ | 2½ | Nomads A |
| 03/02/10 | Ecclesall A | 4 | 4 | Chesterfield A |
| 05/02/10 | Rotherham Jnrs. A | 6 | 2 | Clay Cross |
| 15/02/10 | Chesterfield A | 5½ | 2½ | Barnsley A |
| 15/02/10 | Worksop A | 3½ | 4½ | University A |
| 16/02/10 | Clay Cross | 1 | 7 | Nomads B |
| 17/02/10 | Nomads A | 3½ | 4½ | Ecclesall A |
| 19/02/10 | Rotherham Jnrs. A | 2½ | 5½ | Chesterfield A |
| 22/02/10 | Worksop A | 5 | 3 | Clay Cross |
| 24/02/10 | Ecclesall A | 4 | 4 | Rotherham Jnrs. A |
| 01/03/10 | Chesterfield A | 6 | 2 | University A |
| 03/03/10 | Ecclesall A | 3½ | 4½ | Barnsley A |
| 03/03/10 | Nomads B | 5½ | 2½ | Clay Cross |
| 05/03/10 | Rotherham Jnrs. A | 2½ | 5½ | Nomads A |
| 08/03/10 | Worksop A | 1½ | 6½ | Chesterfield A |
| 09/03/10 | Barnsley A | 4½ | 3½ | Nomads B |
| 15/03/10 | Chesterfield A | 5 | 3 | Nomads B |
| 17/03/10 | Nomads A | 5½ | 2½ | University A |
| 19/03/10 | Rotherham Jnrs. A | 7½ | 0½ | Worksop A |
| 23/03/10 | University A | 4½ | 3½ | Barnsley A |
| 23/03/10 | Clay Cross | 2½ | 5½ | Chesterfield A |
| 24/03/10 | Nomads B | 4 | 4 | Worksop A |
| 30/03/10 | Clay Cross | 3½ | 4½ | Worksop A |
| 31/03/10 | Nomads B | 2 | 6 | Rotherham Jnrs. A |
| 07/04/10 | Ecclesall A | 5 | 3 | Clay Cross |
| 12/04/10 | Worksop A | 4½ | 3½ | Barnsley A |
| 13/04/10 | University A | 4 | 4 | Ecclesall A |
| 14/04/10 | Nomads A | 7 | 1 | Clay Cross |
| 19/04/10 | Chesterfield A | 5 | 3 | Rotherham Jnrs. A |
| 19/04/10 | Barnsley A | 0½ | 7½ | Nomads A |
| 21/04/10 | Ecclesall A | 3½ | 4½ | Worksop A |
| 21/04/10 | Nomads B | 5½ | 2½ | University A |
| 27/04/10 | Clay Cross | 3 | 5 | Rotherham Jnrs. A |
| 27/04/10 | University A | 3½ | 4½ | Chesterfield A |
| 28/04/10 | Ecclesall A | 3 | 5 | Nomads A |
| 28/04/10 | Nomads B | 4 | 4 | Barnsley A |
| 04/05/10 | Barnsley A | 2½ | 5½ | Chesterfield A |